I Want My Beauty Idol

by | Jun 18, 2018 | Beauty, Body Image, Christian Living

Are you a Christian who longs to be more beautiful? Read this!

I’ll admit it. I’ve watched way too many seasons of American Idol.  I liked to pick my faves during auditions and see how far they could go. I loved the emotional drama of Hollywood Week. Yes, I sometimes even voted if I felt a young singer needed my support (much to my husband’s chagrin).

When my picks were booted off? Boy was I bummed. (Sigh. The injustice.)

When American Idol first came out a little part of me was worried about whether or not this show was appropriate for Christians to watch. Though I hadn’t seen the show yet, the title alone concerned me. In Sunday School we learned that anything with the word “idol” in it should be off limits.

Funny thing is, I thought I knew exactly how to follow that first commandment–watching out for anything labeled an idol. I made sure we didn’t have any of those big-bellied Buddha statues on our property. I never surrendered my jewelry to anyone who asked to mold it into a golden calf. Generally, avoid anything with the word idol in it, and I knew I’d be good. (Kind of like avoiding “high fructose corn syrup.”)

But, here’s what I’ve learned about idols–in part from the famous singing show and in part from my own study of scripture. Idols don’t choose their worshippers.  Worshippers choose their idols. 

Just as in the case of American Idol finalists and even winners, some of them will go on to stardom and find themselves idolized (Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson).

Some, probably, will not. (i.e. Lee DeWyze who? He actually won. What happened to him?).

Carrie Underwood by Shelby Casanova. Used under creative commons license.

A Heart of Worship

God created each of us with hearts to worship. We long to follow something or someone.

When that thing or person isn’t God, yet, we pursue it as if it will give us happiness or life it becomes an idol.

It’s that simple.

Sometimes our idols are our dreams (to be a great singer for example). Sometimes our idols are our passions (a love for writing, a heart for justice, etc…). And, sometimes, our idols are people, concepts, or goals; ranging from our families, to success, or even to better health.

In many cases, these dreams, people, or goals are actually good, acceptable, and healthy parts of our lives. Often God even put them there! But, when they are misplaced in importance, when they are prioritized above the one true God, they can (and easily do) become idols.

So, although I’m not even tempted to bow down to a tacky bronze statue, or, even go too gaga over my favorite American Idol vocalist, my heart has idols. One of them I blogged about here, that is: Beauty.

The Idol of Beauty

How does the idol of beauty work? Well, it’s pretty hard to miss.  Unless you live in a cave, everywhere you look beauty is a beckoning god.  The pictures in the magazine say, “look like this and you’ll find happiness.”  The on-screen starlets show us that with the right physical appearance we can have everything this world has to offer.  Even on Idol you can watch phenomenal singers–who should be lauded just for their talent– transform from normal-looking, attractive girls into women that are more inline with what our culture says is gorgeous — and it looks like they are happier because of it.

The subtle lie of the beauty idol is: If you can be beautiful, you can be saved from this world’s problems. If you are beautiful you won’t be mistreated. If you are beautiful everything will always go your way, walking on sunshine so to speak.

So how does this work in my heart?  Truth is: I struggle not to want that beauty.  (I want my beauty idol.) Too often, I buy the lie. I want to look like I’ve been airbrushed.

Some days, in my weakness, I spend way too much time thinking about it, obsessing over it, and working towards it.

Too often I spend more time worrying about what I look like on the outside than I do contemplating the condition of my heart.

I’ll stew and scheme and plan ways that I can lose those 10 “vanity” pounds. But, do I give the same energy to pursuing ways that I can grow in Christ-likeness, holiness, grace, and humility?

Sadly, no. Although I truly want people to think of me as someone who loves others and someone who loves Jesus, I fail as I prioritize and pursue my idol of beauty.

Some days I’m guilty of caring more about whether or not others just think I’m pretty.

Beauty Never Satisfies

Another truth about the idol of beauty: it can never satisfy.

I know many empirically beautiful women who are still vigorously chasing the idol of beauty because with beauty you can never “arrive.”  

You will never reach a point of satisfaction where you can say, “That’s enough. I am beautiful, enough.”

I have friends that have literally won crowns and earned titles that start with a “Miss” –and they would tell you, they still struggle to feel beautiful enough.

When the lie doesn’t pay off like you think it should (i.e. you aren’t blissfully happy)–your only option is to assume you have not yet arrived.

Learning About Modern Day Idolatry

One of the most gifted ministers at discussing the problem of idols in our heart is Dr. Timothy Keller, pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian in New York City. (You can listen to his sermon on idols of the heart, here.)

If this is all new to you –I encourage you to take the time and give it a listen.

Here’s a mini-summary of how he explains idols of the heart and how a Christian should deal with them. The short answer is: we need to repent. And, we need to recognize that Jesus is the only one who will ever be enough.  Whether I’m thinner, taller, tanner, or you name it…there will always be one more thing to improve if I continue to chase the false god of beauty.

But, if I chase Jesus He is enough. He will satisfy. He can offer rest from a race to be “more” that will never be won.  Dr. Keller states:

The essential dynamic of change in the heart of the Christian runs on a cycle of repentance and faith. Repentance is unmasking the idols of the heart, the motivations for action and bases for identity other than Christ, and then taking them to the Cross. Faith is trusting in the forgiveness of Christ, understanding both the depth of our sin and the worth of Christ’s sacrifice.  — Dr. Timothy Keller

Want to break free from Body Image Idolatry? Start here:

Compared to Who Book

[mc4wp_form id= “4141”]


  1. Momma-C

    I’m beginning to think you can read minds too… although maybe I let you in on that little secret already…. sigh, all I can say is… it is so hard. Thanks for keeping it real though, you are one of the few that I know will do that!

  2. karlahess

    Thought-provoking! Idols don’t choose their worshippers…worshippers choose their idols! It struck a chord with me when you mentioned justice as an idol. I don’t think beauty rates as one of mine…but probably knowledge does. Thanks for the nice, post, friend! I’m loving your blog!



  1. The Beauty Trap - Compared to Who? - […] have to admit we are chasing beauty to find a way to escape from the pain of life […]
  2. My Beauty Idol: Mindy's Story - Compared to Who? - […] in my heart. It was on Heather’s blog that I finally found words to piece this all together. I…
  3. Intuitive Eating for Christian Women: Offering Grace for the Wandering Heart - Compared to Who? - […] don’t have to worry and fret that our hearts are little idol factories. Yes, we are prone to wander.…
  4. Everbloom Book Launches Tomorrow! - Compared to Who? - […] me that my heart was bent more towards beauty than it was towards Him. In the revelation of my…
  5. Esther: Beauty for a Purpose - Compared to Who? - […] Ahhh. . . I always envied pageant girls. I knew if there was one group of women who didn’t…
  6. Scarcity Mentality and Body Image: Is There a Connection? - Compared to Who? - […] believe that this world had enough space in it to accept more than one definition of beauty. So, I…
  7. Success Stories and My Story - Compared to Who? - […] did I spend my time thinking about? Well, mostly myself. I thought about my weight, a lot. My overall…
  8. Actions Speak Louder Than Words: Helping Your Daughter With Her Body Image Part 2 - Compared to Who? - […] enough to free me from my slavery to my body image. But, I struggled to recognize that beauty had…
  9. Why "It's What's on the Inside that Counts" Isn't the Best Answer... - Compared to Who? - […] you know, just to make sure it doesn’t work. (I’ve written about this a lot here, and […]
  10. Overcoming Eating Disorders: National Eating Disorder Awareness Week - Compared to Who? - […] Another step on my path to freedom was the recognition of how I’d made my body image an idol.…
  11. The Worst Mother’s Day Ever - […] idolized the concept of […]
  12. The Secret to Losing Weight…Hint: It’s Not in Your Fridge, it’s in Your Heart. | Working Out Love - [...] does it work? Because for many that struggle with our weight– food is an idol.  (I’ve written about modern day…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

compared to who podcast for Christian women body image and insecurity

Buy Me A Coffee