Why I Didn’t Like the Video of Woman They Drew Hearts On

by | Sep 24, 2015 | Comparison, Weight Loss

It’s likely you saw it—the viral video of the woman who stripped down to her black bra and underwear and, using only a chalkboard sign, asked people to show their support for body acceptance by drawing a heart somewhere on her body.

Here’s the video of woman they drew hearts on:

Moving to watch? Sure. To see people, young and old, affirm this woman was nice. How could one not get a case of the warm fuzzies?

Call me stoic, but I didn’t. I don’t think there’s anything awful about what she did. And, I’m glad people were kind to her. I just wish we’d stop thinking that having other people affirm us, no matter what our size, is the answer to our body image issues.

You see, Amy wasn’t actually the first one to do this. A few weeks before Amy’s daring move, a young woman in England did the exact same thing. Watch it here:

But there are two things about these types of videos that trouble me.

First: I feel like this method of promoting body acceptance keeps our focus in the wrong place—on our bodies! 

Stripping-down to get others to accept us seems to prove a point many of us would rather refute. That is, our value is associated with the way our bodies look. By exposing our bodies and then asking for other people to accept them—in the way that both Jae and Amy did in these videos—aren’t we just perpetuating this myth?

If we really want to be counted for who we are on the inside, and not on the outside, how would showing more of our outsides contribute to that goal?

I wonder how different these videos would look if Jae or Amy looked more like my friend Kari—five foot, ten inches, and 110 pounds give or take a few. She’s built like a model. What would the women passing by have thought about having a magazine-cover-worthy body in bra and underwear in the middle of the busy market? Would they draw hearts? Or, would they whisper behind her back, cover their husbands’ eyes and hope she’d put some clothes on? How would we have felt watching a strange man hug her in her underwear, like that man did for Amy?

Our body image issues have so little to do with what we actually look like that I think these “experiments” are futile. I know women who are universally considered beautiful (like Kari) who have people tell them that every single day. Still, they struggle with their value—they strive to look better, to really feel accepted.

Yes, it certainly required inner strength for both of these women to strip down publicly. But, this is not the kind of courage that we need to actually defeat our body image issues.

Self-acceptance sounds desirable. Having others affirm us seems good, too. Yet, what we really need is the courage to derive our affirmation from elsewhere—to, not be overly concerned with what we think of ourselves or what other’s think of us.

And, that’s my next gripe with these videos.Screen Shot 2015-09-16 at 12.02.01 PM

Second: They distract us from focus on where TRUE affirmation comes from.

Yes, it’s wonderful that all those people show their acceptance of these women. But, let’s get real. People are fickle.

They will “love” her today by drawing a heart to honor her brave act. But, will they still “love” her tomorrow if she needs a ride to work? Will they “love” her when she needs a few dollars to cover the rest of the bill at the grocery store? Will they love her when she’s driving too slowly in front of them on a morning they are running late?

Drawing a heart is no more a sign of love than waving at someone is an invitation to dinner. Affirmation that comes from any place other than someone who truly loves us, doesn’t satisfy.

We all seek to be accepted. Yet, we crave someone who not only loves us, but who knows us and still loves us. That’s the only type of affirmation that counts in both our hearts and our heads.

This affirmation is rarely found on earth. Parents try to love their children in this way, as do spouses, and friends. But, we fail. Our love slips. We let each other down.

For the woman with body image issues, shallow affirmation like this has little long term impact. Compliments ricochet right off of her. Accolades of her physical appearance are summarily disregarded by the negative voices in her mind.

Instead of knowing she’s accepted by strangers, what the woman struggling with body image really needs is to discover how accepted she already is by the one who knows her better than anyone else—God. The opinions of man will always fluctuate, as will her opinions of herself. (Our hearts deceive us, remember? We can’t trust our own feelings about our bodies.)

She’ll never please everyone, nor will she ever feel “everyone’s” acceptance. Whether she meets culture’s standard of beauty or never finds it, she’ll still struggle to feel the affirmation of others if she looks for it to give her life.

Instead, because of the amazing love of God through Jesus, she can be okay without their accolades. She doesn’t need strangers to draw hearts on her body because the one who knows her has written his name on her heart.

What did you think of these videos?


  1. Lorrie

    These videos seemed off to me as well. Probably because I have been watching a lot of Tim Keller videos about Idolatry. It just seemed obvious to me that the overarching theme of these videos was to be accepted by people and “Love Yourself”. I realized last year when my father died and my therapist told me in my grief to just “Love myself” that t would not work. She was promoting this same time of self love as these videos demonstrate. I was not a believer yet but I knew that would just end up being selfishness. Something was missing. It wasn’t until heard a sermon about grace that my walls came down that I had up about the Gospel/Jesus. I realized I had been trying to save myself the whole time instead of relying on Jesus to be my savior. I never experienced unconditional love before grace had filled my heart. Without Jesus I know now that our human love is disordered and unhealthy. Without Jesus we will all keep trying to fill that God shaped hole in our hearts with people, success, money, you name it.

    • Heather Creekmore

      Love it Lorrie!! Tim Keller gives it to you straight. 🙂

  2. Carole

    Where is the like button on here? lol Great article Heather. I agree with what you said. And I also find that such an experiment will give healing for a little time…but I bet the next time Amy is in a crowd, she’ll probably still feel very insecure. And those who put hearts on her that day, might still have a judgmental attitude toward a heavy person on another day or in conversations etc; its not a true representation of their heart or hers. I get the concept, but like you..I don’t think it has long term effects.



  1. Do You Have to 'Love' Your Body? A Christian Perspective on Body Positivity - Compared to Who? - […] As Christ followers, we are taught to repent of that pride, to kill it. Not rename it and label…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

compared to who podcast for Christian women body image and insecurity

Buy Me A Coffee

Take the 5-Day Email Challenge!


Thank you, your sign-up request was successful! Please check your e-mail inbox.